← Insights

Search intelligence / Argument

CHRO succession: will your number two get the job?

At listed European companies, 51 in 100 heads of HR came from inside. What decides it is the size of the HR team and how its people were hired.

Article contents 8
  1. 01 How many heads of HR are promoted from inside?
  2. 02 Is the HR team big enough to have a successor?
  3. 03 How does a head of HR build a successor?
  4. 04 Why do companies still hire a head of HR from outside?
  5. 05 A recent case: SD Worx
  6. 06 Four questions for your own team
  7. 07 How we got these numbers
  8. 08 Sources

If you run HR, try this question: if you left tomorrow, would your number two get your job? At listed European companies, about half of heads of HR (the CHRO or HR director) came from inside and half were hired from outside. In our searches, CHRO succession depends on two things. One is how big the HR team is. The other is how the people in it were hired. Both are settled years before anyone resigns.

How many heads of HR are promoted from inside?

Spencer Stuart looked at 2,700 executives at 489 listed European companies. For heads of HR the split is almost even: 51 in 100 came from inside the company and 49 were hired from outside. CEOs come from inside far more often.

Executives who came from inside the company, by job

Executives in post on 30 November 2025 at 489 listed European companies.

JobCame from inside the company
CEO 68%
Operations 67%
Marketing 62%
IT 53%
Legal 53%
HR 51%
Finance 51%

Source: Spencer Stuart, Inside the European C-suite (2026)

When the head of HR was hired from outside, 58 in 100 came from a different industry. That is the highest share of any job in the study.

Is the HR team big enough to have a successor?

Those are large companies, and Italy has fewer of them than its neighbours. Eurostat’s figures show that 26 in 100 Italian workers are in companies with 250 or more staff. In Germany it is 44.5 and in France 46.1.

Workers in companies with 250+ staff, 2024

Share of business-sector jobs: industry, construction and market services.

CountryWorkers in companies with 250+ staff
France 46.1%
Germany 44.5%
EU average (estimate) 36%
Spain 35.5%
Italy 26%

Source: Eurostat, enterprises by size class (sbs_sc_ovw), 2024. The EU figure is a rounded estimate.

Italy sits 10 points below the EU estimate. It has 4,917 companies of that size, and another 26,934 with 50 to 249 staff. Those mid-sized companies have 98 people each on average.

What does that mean for the HR team? A US benchmark from SHRM counts two HR staff for every 100 employees. At 98 people, that is an HR team of two, and a team of two has nobody in the middle to promote. A team with area leads has one or two people who could step up, once their job has been made wider. A team with HR directors should already have a succession line.

How does a head of HR build a successor?

An established head of HR builds that line through hiring. If you pick people at each level who can grow, they take on more as the company grows. By the time you want to leave, someone has already done parts of your job.

The largest US companies fit this picture. Heads of HR promoted from inside in 2025 had spent 11.2 years in the company on average. In Italy, the governance code for listed companies also asks the board to check that succession procedures exist for top management, although it does not name the HR seat.

Why do companies still hire a head of HR from outside?

Having a plan and having a successor are different things. In a 2024 survey by the University of South Carolina, 81 in 100 US heads of HR thought it at least somewhat likely that their successor would come from their own team. Yet only 32 in 100 had got the job that way themselves, and 59 had been hired from outside. The most common reason for an outside hire was that no insider was ready. The same people said two things prepare a successor best: time in front of the board, and a job outside HR.

The choice also belongs to the CEO. At the largest US companies, 31 heads of HR were appointed in 2025, and 47 in 100 new CEOs replaced the head of HR. We see the same in our searches. A client who wants HR run differently usually rules out the insider and looks for someone with no history in the company. That is a fair choice. Our own count for Italy’s largest listed companies is in When the CEO changes, HR follows.

So what we started from holds, in a narrower form. Team size decides whether an inside successor can exist. Hiring and wider jobs decide whether one is ready. The CEO decides whether they are chosen.

A recent case: SD Worx

SD Worx, the European payroll and HR services company, named a new head of HR on 29 October, effective 1 November. She has been in the company for 16 years and ran legal and compliance for nearly five of them. The outgoing head stays on as a part-time adviser.

An inside successor does not have to come from the HR team. At the largest US companies, 13 in 100 of the 31 new heads of HR in 2025 had no HR background, and all of them were insiders.

Four questions for your own team

Is there a layer between you and your specialists? Has someone already run part of your job? Has the CEO seen that person at work? Does the company want HR to carry on as it is?

If any answer is no, hire your next number two with your own job in mind, or plan an outside search early.

For who gets the top HR job for the first time, see Seven in ten CHROs are first-timers in the top HR job. For how we run these searches, see Head of HR search.

How we got these numbers

  • Spencer Stuart (2026): executives in post on 30 November 2025 at 489 companies in 16 European indices; today’s office-holders, not one year’s appointments. Supply chain is left out because the report gives two figures for it.
  • Eurostat, company size (sbs_sc_ovw): industry, construction and market services, 2024, downloaded 16 November 2026. The EU figure is a rounded estimate. Italy moved by at most 0.6 points a year from 2021 to 2024.
  • SHRM (2025): median of 1.98 HR staff per 100 employees, 2,371 US members. No European equivalent found, so the “team of two” is an illustration.
  • Talent Strategy Group (2026): the 31 heads of HR appointed at Fortune 200 companies in 2025; small numbers.
  • University of South Carolina (2024): survey by a US university centre; respondents’ companies and number are not stated.
  • Our searches: the size-and-hiring model is our practitioner observation. We found no count linking HR team size to inside succession.

Sources